Skip to main content

ACT 1963 OBSTRUCTION FOR THE ROSETTA STONE: THE NEW GRAND EGYPTIAN MUSEUM AND THE BRITISH MUSEUM

How do museums build their collections? Have you ever wondered about the collection policies of museums? While the new Grand Egyptian Museum (GEM), which is preparing for its opening in 2023 to become the world's largest archaeological museum, is on our agenda, it is necessary to mention about the collection policies. GEM will house over 100,000 artefacts, include the entirety of Tutankhamun’s treasure displayed together for the first time, and become the largest archaeological museum complex in the world. But... There is something missing in this huge collection. You might be wondering what the British Museum has to do with the opening of the GEM... We can answer it in two words: Rosetta Stone. That stone that cannot be shared and the debate between academics and researchers never ends. Special tours of Grand Egyptian Museum (GEM) have started before the opening, and photos are sent to us. Sharing photos is prohibited after a part of the museum, so we can see it to a certain extent. It has already become clear that it will be a museum that excites us museologists. Returning to our topic: In 2021, more than 2,500 archaeologists signed a petition to repatriate the artefact -the stone- and a YouGov poll on the wider issue of returning artefacts to their country of origin found 62% in favour. (Cover Photograph: Grand Egyptian Museum Official Facebook Page)
So what path will the British Museum follow now? The statement from the British Museum was that they had not received an official request for the return of the Rosetta Stone, but since the 1963 Act prevented its return, the most logical way was to partnership with Egypt’s Ministry of Tourism and Antiquities.

So what is the Act 1963, why is it so restrictive for the British Museum?

The British Museum Act 1963 is an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom and it superseded the British Museum Act 1902. The act prohibits the Museum from disposing of assets, except in a few special circumstances. In May 2005 a judge of the High Court of England and Wales ruled that Nazi-looted Old Master artworks held at the museum could not be returned. The Act also made the Natural History Museum an independent organisation, with its own board of trustees.Photograph: British Museum Official Facebook Page
Since there will be no way a violation of the law for Rosetta Stone, is it possible for the British Museum to become an independent institution with its own board of trustees, like the Natural History Museum? We will see if there is a change in the coming days. A museum can easily follow its reputation - for museum audiences - through 'memes'. If they keen to keep up to date, sure. If we look at the British Museum's reputation over 'art memes', you can see that it is not progressing well. You can Google it for 'British Museum memes' to see them. Of course, this is not the only valid method for perceiving the reputation of a museum, but it is clear that it is effective today. While museums remove borders, they should also cross the borders of social media. When will the British Museum Communications Department take this seriously? It has become important for their corporate identity that they take this situation seriously and take the right steps. For this reason their decision about the Rosetta Stone move will be important.
Destina Hande Cil : 
When examining such collection policies, being limited to a single research will not be enough for you to understand the binding of the law and the operation of museum collection policies. For example, the British Museum can be examined with a single museum collection policy, but the situation is different in museums with many internal stakeholders. For example: Birmingham Museums and Smithsonian Museums are the best examples of this. Some regulations become necessary to prevent the silo effect in the collections. The binding of collections in museums is not only a matter of concern to that country. While the concept of 'internationalization' highlight in museums, it should be a priority to provide new regulations and take steps to support the independent decisions of the institution instead of taking refuge in the bindingness of laws.

What are the collection policies and processes in museums?
  • Acquisition and Accessioning (Inheritance, Exchange, State Transfer, Purchase etc.)
  • Deaccessioning and Disposal (Donations, Transfers, Exchange, Repatriation etc.)
  • Loans and Borrows (Collection items are treated as 'credits' in such cases)
The situation of the British Museum and the Grand Egyptian Museum here will be evaluated in the Collection Policies, under the title of 'Deaccessioning and Disposal' for the British Museum, and under the title of 'Acquisition and Accessioning' for the GEM. As museologists, GEM professionals would not prefer to respond positively to the British Museum's possible 'Loans and Borrows' move and would prefer a permanent move.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

20 MUST-SEE MOVIES AND DOCUMENTARIES ABOUT ART AND MUSEUMS

We can't always watch Rick and Morty and Inside Job , right? ... Right? (Deep silence) Anyway, we should take a break and look at the world of art and culture. Isn't it an ideal day for a dinner and movie duo? (You can adapt it to whatever day you read it) You ordered a delicious meal or cooked that delicious meal that you had in mind since last night , looking for something to watch while you eat it... A TV series? Definitely not... So how about the movie? We already know that it will not end at the same time as the meal - it never progresses in sync, but we should not give up trying - we still made a list. Many movies and documentaries are waiting for you, from those who drink tea with Mussolini to the most famous museums of the world! Here is your list of films and documentaries about art and museums that you must watch : MUSEO (MUSEUM) (2018) Directed by: Alonso Ruizpalacios Starring: Gael García Bernal, Leonardo Ortizgris, Simon Russell Beale, Lynn Gilmartin, Alfredo Cas

NEW TYPES OF MUSEUMS NOT ACCEPTABLE BY ACADEMICS: POP-UP MUSEUMS AND NFT MUSEUM

  One of our museologist academics who also contributed to the construction of many museums and one of the active names in ICOM, stated that she never thought of Pop-Up museums in the category of museums and refused to teach about them within the scope of master's program courses. She doesn't even mention NFT and museums anyway. Do you think that academics' rejection of a type of museum category is reason enough to ignore that type of museum? Of course not. We started talking like Graham Hancock in the Ancient Apocalypse series . Why might some museum categories have difficulty gaining acceptance? What depends on the acceptance of a museum's genre? Based on the data, we mentioned that there are over 104,000 museums in the world. This number is increasing and there are various categories of museums in the world. Do you know the types and categories of museums? Even if you knew by now, new types of museums are still emerging, for example, have you ever heard of the worl